Lubomír Zeman: Thermoplastic injection molding technology and weight reduction of injection moldings, part 4

Lubomír Zeman: Thermoplastic injection molding technology and weight reduction of injection moldings, part 4
Lubomír Zeman, author of the books Vstříkování plastů 1,2 and 3, prepared a professional study on the weight reduction of injected thermoplastics in the automotive industry. In the fourth and final part, the author focused on the assumptions of weight reduction with regard to the environment. In the conclusion, he also compares the density of some polymer materials in relation to the density of metal materials.

PREREQUISITES FOR WEIGHT REDUCTION – DESIGN FOR MANUFACTURABILITY OF THERMOPLASTIC MOULDINGS

Design for manufacturability of thermoplastic mouldings – the term “manufacturability” encompasses one of the most important requirements for the properties of plastic mouldings. Without meeting the requirements encompassed by this term, it is impossible to work with the prerequisites described in the preceding chapters, the prerequisites for reducing the weight of mouldings through the appropriate selection of material and injection moulding technology. 

Design for manufacturability is based on the quality requirements placed on the moulding by its user and is the second step in the pre-production stages for manufacturing thermoplastic mouldings with defined customer quality parameters. The pre-production stages include:

- definition of the requirements for the moulding

- engineering and design of the moulding – in accordance with the principles of design for manufacturability of thermoplastic mouldings

- material selection to meet the requirement to minimise the weight of the moulding

- selection of injection moulding technology from the perspective of producing a moulding with minimum weight

- mouldability analysis

- simulation calculations

- modifications to the moulding design based on feedback from the preceding steps

- production of the moulding using one of the Rapid Prototyping technologies

- production of a prototype mould and prototype mouldings, including its evaluation and any modifications

When carrying out the pre-production stages, it is necessary to bear in mind that if we hand over, or accept for production, production moulds and the mouldings made with them for an inadequately specified moulding – its design, material and quality requirements – nothing will then prevent us from producing mouldings that do not meet the specified quality requirements.

From the perspective of minimising the weight of mouldings, the most important design feature of a moulding is its ribbing – the design of the ribs. Let us therefore ask ourselves – why is it advantageous to design thermoplastic mouldings with ribs? The answer is simple – the moulding will have a reduced weight and the production cycle time will be shortened, while maintaining the mechanical properties of the moulding as if it were made from solid material. This statement is illustrated in Figure 11.

 

A – solid part - moulding design without observing the principles of design for manufacturability – the moulding has a second moment of area of 2 520 mm2 and the holding pressure time was 95 s = 100 %, material = 100 %

B – ribbed part – variant 1 – second moment of area 2 520 mm2, holding pressure time reduced to 35 %, material saving 23 %

C – ribbed part, variant 2 – second moment of area 2 520 mm2, holding pressure time reduced to 15 %, material saving 57 %

 

A – correct ratio of rib thickness to the radius at its junction with the base wall of the moulding

B – radius too large – increased material consumption, longer cycle time

C – rib thickness too large, radius correct – increased material consumption, longer cycle time

D – material accumulation in the corner, corner designed without a radius - increased material consumption, longer cycle time 

E – correct corner design – uniform wall thickness – outer R = inner R + wall thickness

F – areas where sink marks may occur on the outer surface of the moulding wall, potentially also with the possibility of void formation – greatest risk B, C, D

Figure 11: Examples of rib design – design for manufacturability of thermoplastic injection-moulded parts

PREREQUISITES FOR WEIGHT REDUCTION – WEIGHT REDUCTION AND THE ENVIRONMENT

The problems associated with plastics are largely caused by the fact that our production and consumption systems are not sustainable, states a 2025 report by the European Environment Agency (EEA – European Environment Agency, www.eea.europa.eu), with sustainability defined as “meeting the world's needs today and tomorrow by creating systems that allow us to live well and within the limits of our planet”. The general effort to reduce the weight of thermoplastic injection-moulded parts and the approaches described in the preceding chapters can also contribute in some way to this general and rather grand objective. 

This brings the environmental requirements placed on thermoplastic injection-moulded parts into alignment with the requirements for their specific functionality. From the perspective of the previously mentioned life cycle assessment of injection-moulded parts, LCA - Life Cycle Assessment, which is already a standardised method (standard ČSN ISO 14025 Environmental labels and declarations - Type III environmental declarations - Principles and procedures) for calculating the environmental impact of a specific product, emissions data from each stage of the product life cycle are measured, collected and evaluated – Figure 12.      

Figure 12 : Product life cycle and its stages

Stage 1 – Raw material – extraction, sourcing of raw materials / Stage 2 – Processing – production and processing of raw materials / Stage 3 – Transportation – transport of raw materials and products / Stage 4 – Retail and Use – use and trade / Stage 5 – Waste – waste processing

Analysis of the individual stages of the life cycle yields approaches to minimising the environmental impact of an item, product or injection-moulded part. During the design process for the injection-moulded part and its material, the designer or another responsible employee should already carry out alternative calculations of the impact of different designs and material solutions on, for example, CO2 emissions. Among other requirements, the construction and design of injection-moulded parts should follow the principles of design for manufacturability of thermoplastic injection-moulded parts, including circular design requirements, i.e. “trimming” the design to the minimum possible in terms of the part's function – fewer critical geometries that could cause failure of the part or the assembly to which it belongs, as few purely aesthetic features with no functionality as possible, as few parts in assemblies as possible, as many modular designs as possible, as many injection-moulded parts with minimised weight as possible, and as many parts as possible made from materials with a minimised carbon footprint (expressed numerically, this indicates how many kilograms of greenhouse gases a given entity or activity produces, calculated according to ČSN ISO 14067:2013: Greenhouse gases - Carbon footprint of products - Requirements and guidelines for quantification). 

The use of sustainable materials means that they are recyclable and reusable in the greatest possible quantities and to the greatest possible extent, thereby reducing the need to extract and process raw materials for additional virgin materials. It is generally stated that approximately 45 % of all CO2 emissions come from the extraction and production of materials. 

The materials used must be safe for both people and the environment. From this perspective, it is necessary to comply with the current EU chemical safety regulations REACH and RoHS. These are intended to protect both people and the environment from the presence of hazardous materials in new products placed on the European Union market. REACH stands for the registration, evaluation, authorisation and restriction of chemicals (the abbreviation REACH comes from the English "the Registration, Evaluation, Authorisation and Restriction of Chemicals") and RoHS stands for the restriction of hazardous substances in electrical and electronic equipment EEE and in waste electrical and electronic equipment WEEE (the abbreviation RoHS comes from the English “Restriction of the use of certain Hazardous Substances in electrical and electronic equipment”). The regulations overlap in some areas.

In addition to the regulations mentioned above, in the automotive industry every product must have information on its composition so that it can, where appropriate, be used further in accordance with applicable regulations. Each manufacturer is responsible for all aspects – use, withdrawal from service, disposal – of its product – injection-moulded part, as required by the relevant domestic and international legislation – see the regulations mentioned above or, for example, the European Union Directive on end-of-life road vehicles – ELV = “End of Life Vehicles”. Manufacturers must also provide information on the materials used in the product so that the proportion of individual materials in the product and the degree of hazard posed by a given material can be determined.

The above concept of product composition information is implemented in the IMDS system (International Material Data System – International System for Managing Material Data), based on a central database, with registration at https://www.mdsystem.com/imdsnt/ . IMDS is therefore the automotive industry's material data system. The system collects, maintains, analyses and archives all materials used in automotive production. IMDS makes it possible to fulfil the obligations imposed on automotive manufacturers and their suppliers by national and international standards, laws and regulations, and enables automotive manufacturers and their suppliers to standardise their processes and exchange data efficiently.

During the “Use” phase, indoor air pollution in general, and in vehicle interiors in particular, is also an important factor. Increased indoor air pollution is caused by two main factors :

- the use of air conditioning, which results in the accumulation of pollutants in indoor air   

- the emphasis on reducing weight, which, for example in BEV vehicles, has increased due to the weight of the batteries - the introduction of new structural interior materials and composites

Naturally, in addition to the aspects already mentioned, the air inside vehicles is affected by various other air-polluting factors: industrial emissions, smoke and exhaust gases, allergens, pathogens, smog usually consisting of airborne dust, sulphur oxides, nitrogen oxides, ozone, organic gases, etc., including factors originating within the interior itself, from the materials used.  

Polymeric materials used to manufacture vehicle interior components may, at elevated temperatures, emit low-molecular-weight substances that pass into the internal environment – the air - in the vehicle's passenger compartment. Emissions from these materials can be divided into two main groups :

- specific emissions, i.e. emissions that are known and specific to the substances being monitored, such as formaldehyde emitted from POM or thermosets based on phenol-formaldehyde resins

- non-specific emissions, i.e. emissions of a group of substances, usually volatile organic compounds designated by the abbreviation VOC - Volatile Organic Compounds or Chemicals - Volatile organic compounds or chemicals - or SVOC – Semivolatile Organic Compounds or Chemicals - Semi-volatile organic compounds or chemicals, referred to in the automotive industry as FOGGING (fogging)

In addition to the emission behaviour of interior polymeric materials, these materials may give off odours, i.e. they are not sensory-neutral. 

The issue of emissions and odours in vehicle interiors must be addressed from the initial design and engineering considerations, when the correct choice of non-metallic materials can significantly influence the issue, or reduce the potential for emissions from materials, including limiting their odours.

In addition to the engineering approach to minimising emissions and odours - appropriate material selection - it is necessary, if problems arise, to examine the entire production chain - from the use of a suitable material and its correct storage, preparation of the material before it enters the plasticising unit of the injection moulding machine – incorporation of additives, drying - the processing operation itself - temperatures, shear stress during melt preparation, mould design - shear stress, local overheating of the material in the mould cavity, through to operations following the main forming operation, such as painting, laminating, etc., including storage of finished products, their dispatch and transport to the assembly plant. 

The list of requirements for sustainable product design also includes the term “modular design”. At the heart of the idea of modularity in engineering design is the division of complex equipment into modules that can individually be fitted with an increasing number of identical components. Combining these modules makes it possible to cover many variants of standard designs. Thanks to the savings achieved, modular equipment can be manufactured faster and more economically. Moreover, it can be commissioned and expanded quickly thanks to its high flexibility. Typical examples of modular solutions for thermoplastic mouldings include various types of terminal blocks used in virtually all mechanical engineering applications, including the automotive industry. Figure 13 shows examples of modular terminal block solutions manufactured by thermoplastic injection moulding.  

Figure 13 : Examples of modular structures assembled from injection-moulded thermoplastic parts – left: replaceable terminal strip; right: three-dimensional signal distribution unit

For interest, I will also mention the ideas concerning modular design concepts in the automotive industry in the early 1990s. For example, designers at Mercedes-Benz were working at that time on the VRC – Vario Concept Car – concept, Figure 14. The result was a fully functional prototype vehicle combining a convertible, a coupé, an estate and a pick-up. A good range of possible uses for a single car. Its design is nothing particularly impressive, but the vehicle's versatility was exemplary. Unfortunately, however, this concept ended up in a museum after its unveiling in 1994, and Mercedes, like the other car manufacturers (for example Lancia, Chrysler, Citroen, Nissan, Fiat and also Škoda with its Felicia FUN prototype, in which a two-seater pick-up was transformed into a beach vehicle for four by sliding back the rear wall) that were developing similar modular concepts, continues to manufacture only single-purpose cars.  

Figure 14 : Modular vehicle design concept – four in one – Mercedes-Benz VRC

As highlighted throughout this article - in vehicle manufacturing, the use of plastics can not only replace traditional metal materials, but also effectively reduce vehicle weight. Let us explain why this is the case using the example of an exterior component, the Exterior Mirror Cover – Figure 15.   

Figure 15 : Exterior injection-moulded part – Exterior Mirror Cover

Car exterior mirror covers can be classified as exterior and appearance parts. They are usually injection-moulded from ABS, PC/ABS, ASA, PBT + GF, PC and similar materials. We will choose ABS granules as a representative polymer material for injection moulding the Exterior Mirror Cover.

The choice of ABS (an amorphous acrylonitrile-butadiene-styrene copolymer, density 1,045 g.cm-3) or related polymer materials is based on the compatibility (mutual suitability) of its overall properties with the requirements imposed by the automotive industry on this type of part:

- good mechanical properties – impact resistance – the butadiene component of ABS gives the material high toughness, enabling it to withstand impacts from flying debris during vehicle operation and maintenance – washing, parking, including minor collisions during operation, which reduces the risk of damage to the cover; stiffness - acrylonitrile and styrene provide sufficient structural strength to ensure a low degree of deformability during long-term use under various external conditions

- ease of processing – suitability for injection moulding – the portfolio of ABS materials offers a choice of the required flowability in relation to the design of the particular cover; it is suitable for efficient injection moulding of complex geometries; it also enables the production of small features on mirror covers; its properties are well suited to surface appearance treatments – gloss, patterns, textures, painting, metallisation – it is suitable for various aesthetic solutions to meet the requirements of different car models 

- price, weight – compared with the thermoplastics listed above used to manufacture injection-moulded Exterior Mirror Covers, ABS is the most cost-effective – the average price per kilogram of ABS is approximately 2,21 EUR, while the corresponding price for PC is 3,22 EUR; the density of the materials, which determines their weight, is also favourable – ABS 1,045 g.cm-3, ASA 1,07 g.cm-3, PC/ABS 1,15 g.cm-3, PC 1,21 g.cm-3 

- resistance to environmental influences – it meets the automotive industry's temperature resistance requirements of -20 °C to +80 °C (maximum continuous temperature resistance approximately 105 °C); the possibility of incorporating additives to protect against UV radiation and other natural conditions, with a choice of materials whose material data sheets state, for example: High Weatherability (high capability, resistance to weathering) or Wheatherseal applications (suitability for weather-resistant applications)

- safety requirements and regulations – the option to select granules with a UL 94 V-0 flammability rating, meeting the safety requirements of individual car manufacturers – materials are usually included in the list of specific approved materials of the car manufacturer concerned; chemical resistance – data from the granule manufacturer on the chemical stability of the material

- maintenance and sustainability – easy replacement with an original spare part in the event of failure; recyclability – preferably mechanical recycling, the possibility of returning the material to circulation

CONCLUSION

To conclude, I will present several examples demonstrating that, despite problems with end-of-life solutions for thermoplastic injection-moulded parts, they offer advantages both in terms of weight savings compared with traditional metallic materials and in terms of the relationship between weight and mechanical properties. Density, tensile strength and modulus of elasticity themselves are much lower for plastics than for metallic materials, which at first glance puts them at a disadvantage in their use as structural materials. This is in contrast to specific tensile strength, which, in addition to tensile strength itself, also takes into account the density of the particular material. In our case, specific tensile strength is defined as the ratio of tensile strength Rm to the density of the material concerned. Aluminium was used as the reference when determining specific tensile strength - its dimensionless value was set at 1. The other tensile strength values are therefore divided by the strength of aluminium, giving relative values that illustrate how the dimensionless specific tensile strength of a given polymer differs from the specific tensile strength of aluminium.

A comparison of the density of certain polymeric materials with the density of metallic materials is shown in the following figures – Figures 18, 22, as are comparisons of tensile strength Rm - Figures 19, 23 and specific tensile strength Rms - Figures 16, 17, 20, 21, 24, 25.

Figure 16 : Comparison of the specific tensile strength of polyolefins – PE,PP – with metallic materials
Figure 17 : Comparison of the specific tensile strength of unfilled amorphous polymeric materials with metallic materials
Figure 18 : Comparison of the density of selected structural composite materials with a polymer matrix – SV 30 – and unfilled polymeric materials – POM, PVC (PAK = polyester alkyd = thermoset) - with metallic materials
Figure 19 : Comparison of the tensile strength of selected structural composite materials with a polymer matrix – SV 30 – and unfilled polymeric materials – POM, PVC (PAK = polyester alkyd = thermoset) - with metallic materials
Figure 20 : Comparison of the specific tensile strength of selected composite materials with a semi-crystalline polymer matrix and fibrous filler – SV 30 - unfilled semi-crystalline polymeric materials – POM (PAK = polyester alkyd = thermoset) - with metallic materials
Figure 21 : Comparison of the specific tensile strength of composite materials with an amorphous polymer matrix and fibrous filler – SV 30 – and unfilled amorphous unplasticised PVC with metallic materials
Figure 22 : Comparison of the density of high-tech polymeric materials – unfilled semi-crystalline materials PI, PTFE, PEEK; a composite with a semi-crystalline matrix PEI SV 30; composites with an amorphous matrix PPS, PSU – SV 30 - with metallic materials
Figure 23 : Comparison of the tensile strength of high-tech polymeric materials – unfilled semi-crystalline materials PI, PTFE, PEEK; a composite with a semi-crystalline matrix PEI SV 30; composites with an amorphous matrix PPS, PSU – SV 30 - with metallic materials
Figure 24 : Comparison of the specific tensile strength of high-tech unfilled semi-crystalline polymeric materials – PI, PTFE, PEEK – and a composite with a semi-crystalline matrix and glass fibre PEI SV 30 - with metallic materials
Figure 25 : Comparison of the specific tensile strength of high-tech polymer composite materials with an amorphous matrix and 30 % glass fibre with metallic materials

End of the final part. 

You can find the first part here.
You can find the second part here.
You can find the third part here. 

Author: Ing. Lubomír Zeman
Share:

Suppliers on this topic

You Might Also Be Interested In

ALLROUNDER e TREND: ARBURG Sets a new standard in electric injection moulding machines

21.9.2026 Rising energy costs, pressure to improve production efficiency and a shortage of skilled workers are changing how plastics processors assess new investments. ARBURG is responding to these trends with the launch of its new ALLROUNDER e TREND series...